
A Virginia man who admitted on the witness stand that he cut up his wife’s body was convicted of her murder, after jurors rejected his claim that she took her own life.
Story Highlights
- A jury found Naresh Bhatt guilty of first-degree murder in the death of his wife, Mamta Kafle, whose body has never been found.
- Bhatt testified that he found her dead, then used a saw to cut up her body so it would fit in a trash can. He claimed she died by suicide.
- Prosecutors said his web searches, purchases and cover-up showed months of planning.
- Bhatt faces at least 20 years and up to life in prison when he is sentenced on March 12, 2027.
- Prosecutors said Bhatt handed the power saw to a landscaper as payment for about $40 of yard work; the landscaper later turned it over to police.
Jury Reaches Murder Verdict After Evidence-Heavy Trial
On Tuesday, November 10, a Prince William County jury convicted Naresh Bhatt of first-degree murder, concealing a dead body and defiling a dead body in the death of his wife, Mamta Kafle. First-degree murder in Virginia means a killing that was willful and planned ahead of time, and that is what prosecutors set out to prove. Prosecutor Sarah Sami told jurors that Bhatt’s internet searches, his purchases and his work to hide her death showed months of planning. “He was the only one with motive, opportunity and intent,” she said. The jury of eight women and four men deliberated a little over four hours after a 19-day trial.
Kafle was 28 and the mother of a baby girl when she vanished from the couple’s Manassas Park home in July 2024. She had started a job at UVA Health Prince William Medical Center that month. Before trial, Bhatt told police and reporters that she had left home and was likely in New York or Texas. At trial, he changed his story. He admitted that he dismembered her body and threw it away. Judge Kimberly Irving set sentencing for March 12, 2027. The murder conviction carries 20 years to life, and each of the other two charges carries up to five years. “Defiling” a body is the legal term for cutting up or mistreating a dead body.
Forensic Links And Dumpster Trips Undercut The Defense
Prosecutors showed surveillance videos of Bhatt, wearing gloves, throwing bags into trash dumpsters in different places across Northern Virginia. Reports said he made at least five dumpster trips over two days. Bhatt said the bags held only her belongings, not her remains. Sami told jurors he left her remains at a landfill in Luray, Virginia. “The defendant murdered Mamta Kafle, the defendant dismembered Mamta Kafle and the defendant got rid of her like garbage,” she said.
A power saw was key evidence. Prosecutors said Bhatt handed the saw to a landscaper as payment for about $40 of yard work shortly after his wife went missing. Weeks later, the landscaper heard about Bhatt’s arrest and turned the saw over to police. Forensic examiners found Kafle’s blood and DNA inside it. Investigators also told jurors about web searches, including “what happens if a spouse disappears” in March 2024, searches about meat cutters and saws, and “can I donate my baby to my friend?” The defense pointed out that several searches had no time stamps.
Defense Suicide Story And PTSD Claim Fail To Sway Jurors
Bhatt took the stand and said he found his wife on their bedroom floor on July 30, 2024, after she swallowed a pesticide. He said he tried to revive her and could not. He said he did not call 911. “I really at that point scared. I don’t know why I did not,” he testified. A defense psychologist said Bhatt meets the criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD, a condition that can follow a deep shock or trauma. Bhatt suggested that finding her dead set it off.
On cross-examination, prosecutor Matthew Sweet told him, “You’re a liar.” Bhatt answered, “Yes.” Defense attorney Tracey Lenox, the area’s chief public defender, argued that “the commonwealth has not ruled out suicide as the reason for the physical evidence they showed you.” Kafle’s mother and brother testified that she had plans for her daughter’s future and would never take her own life. A friend testified that Kafle told her Bhatt had abused her. Sami summed up his story this way: “He had to admit what he could not deny and deny what he could not admit.”
What This Case Says About Justice And Public Safety
This verdict shows that a killer cannot escape the law by making a body disappear. Video, lab work and a digital trail gave the jury what it needed, and Bhatt’s own lies did the rest. Commonwealth’s Attorney Amy Ashworth called the verdict “an important measure of justice for Mamta Kafle Bhatt.”
Kafle’s friends wore red, her favorite color, to court. “Whatever lies you told, you didn’t erase Mamta,” said her friend Holly Wirth. Another friend, Sunita Basnet Thapa, said, “Finally, Mamta can rest in peace.” Her daughter was not yet one year old when her mother vanished.
Sources:
nbcwashington.com, princewilliamtimes.com, wjla.com, fox5ny.com, princewilliamtimes.com, dcnewsnow.com









