
A severed head found in a Foresthill trash bag in 2022 led to the arrest of the victim’s wife and daughter after a DNA breakthrough.
Story Highlights
- Deputies found a severed head in a trash bag near Foresthill in 2022.
- DNA and family-tree work identified the victim as 73-year-old Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr..
- Officials arrested his wife, Mary, for suspected murder and daughter, Georgia “Gwenn,” as an alleged accessory.
- Investigators say Fitzmaurice was never reported missing, adding to concealment concerns.
Severed Head Discovery in 2022 Sparked a Long, Careful Investigation
Placer County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded on September 28, 2022, after a person walking a dog found a severed human head in a trash bag in the Todd Valley area near Foresthill, California. Detectives secured the scene and began processing evidence. Officials did not locate the rest of the remains at the site, which made identification harder. Investigators treated the area as a homicide scene from the start. The graphic discovery shocked residents in nearby communities and drew sustained law enforcement attention.
Deputies and crime scene staff collected the bag and biological evidence for testing. Investigators compared the head against missing-person reports and open cases but found no quick match. The Sheriff’s Office asked regional partners for help and kept the case active. The lack of a reported missing person in the right timeframe made the case unusual. Detectives pressed on with forensic options, knowing time would complicate leads. The case became a priority as a potential homicide with no named victim.
Genetic Genealogy and Federal Help Identified the Victim
A private laboratory produced a lead through forensic genetic genealogy that pointed to distant relatives of the unknown man. The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) assisted with interviews and family-tree research to refine the lead to a likely family branch. Investigators then sought a closer relative’s DNA outside California to confirm the identity. Testing matched the remains to 73-year-old Citrus Heights resident, Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., which gave detectives a name and a path forward.
With identity confirmed, detectives mapped Paul’s last known ties to Citrus Heights and re-interviewed contacts. The Sheriff’s Office coordinated with local agencies to build a timeline. Officials reported that Fitzmaurice had not been reported missing, which raised questions about his daily life and finances. Authorities did not release an exact cause, date, or location of death, citing active investigative work. The confirmation still marked a turning point by turning an unknown victim case into a targeted homicide probe.
Search Warrant at Family Home Led to Two Arrests
Detectives served a search warrant at the family’s Citrus Heights residence on November 17 and made two arrests later that day. Sheriff Wayne Woo said his office arrested Mary Fitzmaurice and her daughter, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, in connection with Paul’s death. Officials booked Mary on suspicion of murder. They booked Gwenn as an alleged accessory. Prosecutors were reviewing evidence and considering additional charges at the time of reporting. The Sheriff credited the careful, multi-year work that supported the arrests.
Several outlets reported claims that financial benefits may have continued after Paul’s death, including pension payments, but public records on any fraud charge were not available in the cited reports. Authorities have not detailed the physical evidence that ties each suspect to the alleged crime. Officials also have not released the autopsy results. The Sheriff’s Office emphasized that the arrests followed the DNA identification and subsequent search findings, while the court process will determine guilt.
Public Safety, Rule of Law, and a Reminder for Families and Neighbors
This case shows what steady police work and modern DNA tools can deliver. A nameless victim gained a voice, and suspects now face court review. Families, churches, and neighbors can help by reporting concerns early, especially when a senior suddenly “disappears” without notice. Local law enforcement depends on tips and welfare checks. Community watch and honest records guard both safety and taxpayer funds. When systems work together, justice gets a fighting chance, and the rule of law stands a little taller.
Sources:
foxnews.com, kbtx.com, sacbee.com, kcra.com, krcrtv.com, the-independent.com









